This year, buying Christmas gifts for Boo and Lu was going to be so simple! They both wanted Play Doh. (The kind that comes in a kit to make princess dresses, hamburgers . . . stuff like that.) They picked out their favorite kits, and I breathed a sigh of relief that Santa would have it really easy this year . . . that is until my mom and sister pointed out that Play Doh is not gluten free. What???? I totally forgot!
Since no mom wants to deny her child's reasonable gift requests, I set to work making my own Gluten Free Play Dough. But which recipe to choose? I would need lots of dough, so why not try a few and share my results with you? That's exactly what I did.
1 Mom + 3 Recipes + a few hours kiddo free and lots of rice flour = Tons of play dough and very sore forearm muscles!!!
I tried three recipes:
- Gluten-Free Play Dough (originally from the Celiac Disease Foundation)
- Easiest Gluten Free Play Dough Recipe from Celiac Family
- Kool-Aid Gluten Free Play Dough from Celiac Family
Here's what I learned: They all result in nice play dough that matches the texture of real Play Doh. They also all require adding extra corn starch and kneading--a lot. They all work just as well as regular Play Doh. Which is best? It depends on what you are looking for.
My favorite: Easiest Gluten Free Play Dough Recipe from Celiac Family
Why? It makes the most dough (although the others are pretty close), and it turns out very white. I like the white because it makes the prettiest colors, and it's the only recipe that can actually be used as white. (Gotta have white!)
2nd favorite: (Recipe below)
Gluten-Free Play Dough from the Celiac Disease Foundation--It's all over the web and in magazines, so I feel okay about sharing it here:
- ½ cup rice flour
- ½ cup cornstarch
- ½ cup salt
- 2 teaspoons cream of tartar
- 1 cup water
- 1 teaspoon cooking oil
- Food coloring, if desired
Mix ingredients. Cook and stir on low heat for 3 minutes or until it forms a ball. Cool completely before storing in a sealable plastic bag.
This one works nicely, but the color is more of a pale cream. If you don't need to make white, it should work fine.
Least favorite: Kool-Aid Gluten Free Play Dough
This recipe would be perfect if you want to make a batch for lots of kids to use the same color. My goal was to make lots of colors, so this wasn't a smart choice for me. I made orange dough and successfully recolored it to an ugly red, a brown that matches a color you might find on your shoe after walking the dog, and a glittery orange. I hated the smell of orange Kool-Aid after about three minutes of kneading the dough.
Get the recipe here. (This is the same link as above. Both recipes are in the same post.)
As usual, I made all of the mistakes so that you don't have to! Here are some final tips to make your dough mimic the dough that comes with the fancy kits.
- When adding food coloring, don't forget what you learned in elementary school! First add the lightest color, mix well, and then add the darker color a little bit at a time. I tried to make purple, but accidentally added blue food coloring first. I ended up with a nice gray instead! (I added fine glitter, and it now looks silver. I actually wanted silver, so it was a happy accident.)
- It is difficult to create dark colors. Plan on adding lots of food coloring!!!
- You can mimic the fancy glitter Play Doh! Just make a well in the dough, dump in some fine glitter, and knead it like crazy! It comes in lots of colors. My kids love the glitter dough.
3 batches of dough made enough for two gifts of ten colors each.
So, are you wondering what Santa did about the Play Doh kits my kids wanted? I let him know that I'd take care of the Play Dough, and assigned him something else. Yes. I did buy the kits. That means I payed for Play Doh that my kids won't be able to use. They kept the design tools, and the Play Doh will be given as birthday gifts to their friends. I'm very happy with the result. Happy kids who don't feel deprived because of Celiac!
Want more kid-friendly gluten free recipes? You might like these: